Uncategorized
Healthcare delivery systems
HSA 1100 – US HEALTH CARE DELIVERY SYSTEMS
Health Reform Paper Rubric
| Criteria | Rating | Points | ||
| Introduction | Met: Clear indication of the purpose of the paper and clearly states topics which will be covered in the paper and writer’s position.
10.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: The purpose of the paper is somewhat stated or the topics/positions addressed in the paper are not clear.
5.0 pts
|
Not Met: Purpose not stated.
0.0 pts |
|
| Body | Met: Describes in detail the position(s) taken.
40.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: Position taken is on somewhat described.
20.0 pts
|
Not Met: No position is
taken.
0.0 pts
|
|
| References | Met: Uses at least three references to justify position taken. Sources are from scholarly journals/national organizations. Clearly states the reference. Synthesizes the material from the references, does not just regurgitate or over-quote.
15.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: Only 1-2 references used, or some references do not justify position, or the references only somewhat synthesizes the material, but primarily regurgitates material or over-quotes.
7.0 pts
|
Not Met: No references or does not synthesize the material.
0.0 pts
|
|
| Conclusion | Met: Summarizes the major justification for the position taken and reviews information from body.
15.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: Only some of the major justifications for the position taken are summarized or does not provide a complete summary of body of paper.
7.0 pts
|
Not Met: Major justifications for the position taken are not summarized.
0.0 pts
|
|
| Grammar/Writing
|
Met: Less than 6 errors in grammar or spelling. Apparent effort made to proof. Written at graduate level, using appropriate medical/nursing terminology.
20.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: 6-10 errors in grammar or spelling. Limited efforts to proof. Some attempts to write to graduate level, but uses inappropriate terminology or
language.
10.0 pts
|
Not Met: More than 10 errors in
grammar or spelling. No efforts to proof are apparent. Not indicative of a graduate level written paper.
0.0 pts
|
|
| APA | Met: Less than 3 errors in APA formatting.
15.0 pts
|
Somewhat Met: 4-7 errors in APA formatting.
10.0 pts
|
Not Met: More than 7 errors in APA formatting. Did not appear to attempt to follow APA or proof.
0.0 pts
|
|
| Logical Flow | Smooth transitions – well written. Limited run-on sentences
15.0 pts
|
Transitions are adequate, some run on sentences.
7.0 pts
|
Poorly written with orphan sentences and run on sentences – difficult to read.
0.0 pts
|
|